“If Shuji didn't say they are forged, I consider them as a valid evidence. ”
I pray you never make ASim.
Or worse, a RL judge. Or cop. Or, well, anything associated with justice being done.
“Shuji didn't need to say/imply it was a bug for an Asim to get involved. If I were in Kir's shoes, I would have filed a bug report or contacted an Asim myself (without Shuji needing to claim it to be a bug). The situation is what is implying that there was a bug, not Shuji himself. ”
It's a trade dispute. ASims do not get involved in trade disputes. Lying is a legal IC action. There are years
of precedents for it.
If Shuji SAID it was a bug, that's a different matter. It's also a world of difference between Xabia saying "it's a known bug, send again" and Shuji mentioning that the game is bug-ridden. IF he did, it was a poor choice. BUT, there was no proof that he did when Jenos banned him.
Evidence first. Ban second.